Risk Regulation and Administrative Constitutionalism

...an impressive book that manages to combine a singularity of focus with an extraordinary breadth of research. It makes an important contribution to the literature on risk regulation, administrative law, and socio-legal studies generally...These are Elizabeth Fisher's ideas, claims and hypotheses; there is no hiding behind canon or behind superficially neutral 'we' statements. Fisher's Risk Regulation and Administrative Constitutionalism is a courageous and original monograph. It is the kind of work that will inspire scholars and reward readers for many years to come. Veerle Heyvaert Modern Law Review 72 (5), 2009 Fisher's...particularly significant contribution to these discussions is her shift away from the relatively well-considered debates on the use of scientific evidence in claims for liability or when drafting legislation to the coal face of public administration and (in her terminology) 'administrative constitutionalism'...Overall, Fisher's analysis is rarely prescriptive, preferring to describe what is happening in her chosen 'snapshots' of risk evaluation, offering an analytical lens for further analysis...her section on preliminary findings is tantalisingly short and, one suspects, an aspect of the book that may be further developed in future articles. These will no doubt be as thoughtful and insightful as the book itself, and well worth the wait. Antonia Layard Journal of Environmental Law August 2008 The case studies are interesting in themselves. Fisher's treatments of the role of expertise in the British BSE inquiry and of the complexities of risk regulation through specialised courts in Australia are particularly illuminating...By moving away from the simple 'science versus democracy' dichotomy, Fisher clearly advances our understanding of risk regulation and administrative law. Her work opens the way to even more textured accounts of the relevant legal cultures. Mark Tushnet European Law Journal Vol. 14, No. 5, September 2008 Anyone embarking on this type of research, whether empirical or normative, or on research involving the wider themes of institutional dynamics and legitimating discourses that shape regulation will find inspiration in the challenging tone and analytical richness of Risk Regulation and Administrative Constitutionalism. Anne Meuwese Journal of Law and Society Vol. 35, No. 3, 2008 In meticulous detail, Fisher maps the two theories onto the actors and the proceedings of these case studies. The schema set out in this book are compelling, and serious readers will find themselves better-equipped to comprehend the problems and the potentials, the vagaries and the constants, of public administration. David Frankel Journal of International Law and Politics Volume 41, Number 3 Her discussion reveals a considerable depth and breadth of thinking and understanding on the issues Lynda M Warren Environmental Law Review Volume 11, Number 3, 2009