An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy

This insightful examination of philosophy delves into Mill's critiques and revisions, showcasing his engagement with contemporary thought in An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy.

The introduction by John M. Robson provides valuable context for An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy, exploring the significant events of Mill's life during the 1860s. It outlines the composition of the treatise, highlighting the extensive revisions made by Mill, primarily in response to critiques from his contemporaries. These revisions are crucial for understanding the evolution of Mill's thoughts and the impact of external opinions on his work.

Originally published in 1865, with subsequent editions released in the same year and later in 1867 and 1872, An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy gained considerable attention and popularity among Mill's contemporaries. This work delves deeply into topics central to empiricism, which Mill had only briefly touched upon in his earlier work, Logic. Notably, his exploration of the relationship between matter and mind from a psychological perspective is a significant contribution to philosophical discourse.

The treatise emerged at a pivotal moment in Mill's career, coinciding with his successful parliamentary candidacy. It boldly challenged intuitionist views, which Mill associated with regressive political and religious ideologies. This public stance led to both support and criticism, as some of Mill's political allies faced backlash for their association with his controversial ideas. Alan Ryan's analytical introduction further contextualizes the philosophical elements within the work, emphasizing their relevance to Mill's broader body of thought.