Medieval Islamic Historiography

This work delves into the historiography of Uthman b. Affan, revealing how narratives evolved to depict him favorably, influencing contemporary debates.

This book offers a comparative analysis of medieval Sunni historiography, focusing on the caliphate of Uthman b. Affan and the subsequent revolt against him. By examining various treatments of Uthman in both pietistic literature and universal chronicles, Medieval Islamic Historiography reveals how critical perspectives were gradually silenced in favor of narratives that framed Uthman as a saintly figure and a companion of the Prophet Muhammad.

Through a meticulous comparison of different authors across genres and time periods, the book illustrates how personal viewpoints shaped the historical narrative surrounding significant religio-political tensions that arose during Uthman's rule. These tensions include the divide between Sunnis and Shiis, the struggle for religious and political authority, and the contrasting appeals for stability and unity versus the demand for greater justice. The debates initiated by the revolt against Uthman resonate with contemporary issues, making this analysis particularly relevant today.

Medieval Islamic Historiography not only sheds light on historical events but also provides valuable context for understanding ongoing debates in the modern world, such as those seen during the Arab Spring. By connecting past and present, the book encourages readers to reflect on the implications of historiography in shaping collective memory and identity within Islamic discourse.