The Disappearing First Amendment

Ronald J Krotoszynski, Jr author

Format:Hardback

Publisher:Cambridge University Press

Published:3rd Oct '19

Currently unavailable, and unfortunately no date known when it will be back

This hardback is available in another edition too:

The Disappearing First Amendment cover

This book explores how the Supreme Court upholds rules against content and viewpoint discrimination while often neglecting to protect ordinary citizens' expressive freedoms, particularly when they need government assistance to speak.

The Disappearing First Amendment by Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr. explores the complexities of First Amendment rights as interpreted by the Supreme Court. The author argues that while the Court has been diligent in enforcing rules against content and viewpoint discrimination, it has not been as effective in protecting the free speech rights of ordinary citizens, particularly when they require government support to express their views. This discrepancy raises important questions about the role of the government in facilitating public discourse.

Krotoszynski critiques the prevailing narrative that the Supreme Court has consistently expanded free speech rights over time. He acknowledges that this is true in certain contexts, but highlights significant areas where the Court's decisions have curtailed these rights. For instance, when citizens seek access to public spaces for protests or demonstrations, they often encounter obstacles that undermine their ability to speak freely. The author points out that the Roberts and Rehnquist Courts have favored strict, categorical rules over more flexible balancing tests, which limits judicial discretion and, consequently, citizens' opportunities for meaningful democratic engagement.

The book advocates for a return to the Warren Court's approach, which allowed for greater judicial discretion in assessing free speech cases. Krotoszynski believes that empowering federal judges to require government assistance for would-be speakers could enhance democratic participation and strengthen the foundations of free speech. The Disappearing First Amendment is a thought-provoking read for anyone interested in the current state of free speech and its implications for democracy.

'Krotoszynski, Jr. convincingly advances a powerful thesis while at the same time offering the best available comprehensive account of how the freedom of speech has been interpreted and debated during the last few decades. He demonstrates in riveting detail how certain would-be contributors to public debate such as impecunious protestors, whistleblowers within government, and journalists have seen their First Amendment rights confined or rolled back in recent years even as the Supreme Court has recognized dubious new free speech rights which benefit business entities.' Vincent Blasi, Columbia University, New York
'Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr. tells the depressing story of how the Warren Court opened up the possibility for a First Amendment interpreted broadly to advance democracy in a modern society in which private power can dominate politics, only to have later Courts sharply narrow that possibility. Yet he also shows how existing doctrine can be developed to give us a First Amendment better suited to creating and supporting a truly democratic political culture. The argument is provocative and subtle, and deserves close attention.' Mark Tushnet, Harvard University, Massachusetts
'Freedom of speech isn't free, but it should be available to employees, not just employers, to people of modest means, not just the wealthy. So argues Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr. in this timely and trenchant critique of the Roberts Court. Krotoszynski, Jr. would reorient First Amendment jurisprudence away from the interests of the rich and powerful and back towards rules and standards that protect what Hugo Black once called 'the poorly financed causes of little people'.' Michael C. Dorf, Cornell University, New York
'This important book from one of the country's leading First Amendment scholars highlights pitfalls in modern First Amendment doctrine and suggests how courts can strengthen protections for our expressive and democratic interests.' John Inazu, Washington University
'Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr. has written an important corrective to the misleading narrative that Americans' expressive rights have unfailingly expanded. To the contrary, as he shows, the Supreme Court's rigid doctrines have shrunk our expressive topography, limited opportunities for transborder exchange, and stripped government employees and students of critical First Amendment rights.' Timothy Zick, College of William and Mary
'Constitutional scholars will find this text valuable in highlighting important, often ignored Supreme Court cases and in drawing connections between the court's subtle jurisprudential shifts and the democratic institutions the doctrine is intended to serve.' D. E. Smith, Choice

ISBN: 9781108481540

Dimensions: 235mm x 155mm x 25mm

Weight: 700g

384 pages