Constitutional Triumphs, Constitutional Disappointments

This book evaluates the successes and failures of the 1996 South African Constitution, offering insights into its impact on both national and global constitutionalism.

This insightful work delves into the aspirations set forth by the 1996 South African Constitution and examines whether these goals have been realized over the years. Co-edited by Rosalind Dixon and Theunis Roux, Constitutional Triumphs, Constitutional Disappointments offers a comprehensive analysis of South Africa's post-apartheid legal framework, focusing on both its achievements and shortcomings. It provides a unique perspective on how other nations can learn from South Africa's experiences in constitutional governance.

The book explores the promise of the Constitution, which aimed to reshape the nation along non-racial and egalitarian lines. Following its twentieth anniversary, the volume reflects on the various arguments surrounding the Constitution's effectiveness. Some scholars advocate for the creation of a new, authentically African document, free from the compromises made during the transition from apartheid. In contrast, others argue that the existing Constitution remains a significant attempt to establish a society grounded in social, economic, and political rights for all citizens.

Constitutional Triumphs, Constitutional Disappointments also addresses the ongoing debates regarding whether South Africa's current challenges stem from constitutional design flaws or issues with implementation. Additionally, the book assesses the Constitution's impact on global constitutionalism, providing valuable insights into how it has influenced democratic practices beyond its borders. This volume is essential for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of constitutional law in South Africa and its relevance in a broader context.