Stanley Fish on Philosophy, Politics and Law

This book explores Fish's unconventional positions on politics and law, explaining how they flow from his positions on three philosophical issues.

Stanley Fish is a provocative author who is often misunderstood precisely because of his polemical approach. This book sets out and evaluates his arguments in a clear fashion which makes his contribution to philosophy, politics and law more accessible for both generalist and specialist readers.Fish's writings on philosophy, politics and law comprise numerous books and articles produced over many decades. This book connects those dots in order to reveal the overall structure of his argument and to demonstrate how his work in politics and law flows logically from his philosophical stands on the nature of the self, epistemology and the role of theory. Michael Robertson considers Fish's political critiques of liberalism, critical theory, postmodernism and pragmatism before turning to his observations on political substance and political practice. The detailed analysis of Fish's jurisprudence explores his relationships to legal positivism, legal formalism, legal realism and critical legal studies, as well as his debate with Ronald Dworkin. Gaps and inconsistencies in Fish's arguments are fully explored, and the author provides a description of Fish's own positive account of law and deals with the charge that Fish is an indeterminacy theorist who undermines the rule of law.