A Life in Shadow

"Bell's book is a praiseworthy, highly readable, and most welcome account of Bonpland's last forty years of life, spent in various places and in different activities in the southern part of the continent. This account is based on a thorough effort to collect and systematically analyze, from an original perspective, a wealth of documents that until now had remained only partially or poorly executed . . . [A Life in Shadow] also illuminated often overlooked, but highly significant aspects of the social and economic dimensions of life in various regions of the southern part of the continent during the first half of the nineteenth century. Thus, the book is recommended reading for an audience whose interests range beyond the biographical dimensions of a unique European intellectual with broad domains of activity and deep involvement in American life, to readers who are also interested in the early history of scientific activities in the continent." -- Leo Corry * Estudios Interdisciplinarios de America Latina y el Caribe *
"This well-researched, insightful book is recommended to students and professionals in Latin American history and political science." -- Colonial Latin American Historical Review
"This most impressive work of historical scholarship is the result of research conducted over the better part of two decades by Stephen Bell, who is indubitably the world authority on Bonpland . . . Bell gets the very best out of his materials in etching this monographic portrait, as well as augmenting the larger, cosmopolitan portrait that we know rather better by dint of those letters that crossed the Atlantic eastwards. As a professional geographer, he helps the reader with the (many) scientific terms required for a close understanding of Bonpland's experiments, and his department at UCLA has provided us with a ne map through which to trace the peregrinations of four decades. The book is densely populated with learned footnotes (wherein one can almost follow a subsidiary story as well as the comprehensive references)." -- James Dunkerley * Journal of Latin American Studies *
"Bell's book is both the best and the most complete study ever written on this key figure in South American science and exploration. Bell should be congratulated for having put together a veritable jigsaw of materials on an important topic and having done so in a readable, well-focused way." -- Thomas Whigham * University of Georgia *
"[A Life in Shadow] is a wonderful contribution to scholarship on science in Latin America, and also to the understanding of the relationship between science and culture during the first half of the nineteenth century. It is also a perfect illustration of how scientific thought and location work together . . . [W]ithout a doubt, this book will be a mandatory reference for all future publications of the subject, as it will be for anybody interested in the science of this period, whether from a Latin American or European perspective." -- Adriana Novoa * H-Net *
"Along the book, Bonpland emerges as a key element of the circuits of exchange of data, information, and natural history collections that connected European and South American worlds. Moreover, this book displays how the scientific endeavors of Bonpland cannot be separated from his interests in commerce of local products, the adaptation of exotic species to South American environments, his connections with the French merchant houses, and the importance of the navigation routes of the Parana river for scientific exploration, the trade and international politics. Bell's book is a clear indication that history of science and rural history can learn from each other." -- Irina Podgorny * Canadian Journal of History *
"Stephen Bell's book convincingly shows that Bonpland deserves much more than a quick footnote in the historical studies of nineteenth-century European and Latin American natural history, science, and agriculture . . . The greatest strength of the book is the superb research in archives and primary sources carried out by the author . . . Bell has produced an excellent work that will interest many scholars. By constantly and aptly contextualizing Bonpland's life the book turns out to be about much more than just this French naturalist; rather, it conveys important reflections on southern South American history." -- Camilo Quintero Toro * Hispanic American Historical Review *