The Philosophers' Quarrel

This book delves into the tumultuous friendship and subsequent fallout between Enlightenment philosophers Jean-Jacques Rousseau and David Hume, exploring their intellectual clash and its broader implications for society and thought.

"The Philosophers' Quarrel" delves into the tumultuous relationship between two prominent Enlightenment thinkers, Jean-Jacques Rousseau and David Hume. Their friendship, which flourished for a mere six months, ended in a dramatic and public fallout that captured the attention of intellectuals and the general public alike. The authors, Robert Zaretsky and John T. Scott, meticulously explore the dynamics of this rift, illustrating how it reflected broader themes of human understanding and philosophical inquiry.

The book not only chronicles the breakdown of Rousseau and Hume's friendship but also examines the correspondence that ensued, filled with animosity and misunderstanding. These letters, which were quickly published, ignited fervent debates among aristocrats and thinkers of the time, leading to a division of allegiances. Zaretsky and Scott emphasize how this quarrel was not merely a personal dispute but a significant moment in the history of ideas, revealing the vulnerabilities and limitations of both philosophers.

Furthermore, the authors situate this conflict within the rich social and political context of the 18th century, considering the influence of contemporaries such as James Boswell, Adam Smith, and Voltaire. By analyzing the philosophical contributions of Rousseau and Hume, the book highlights the enduring impact of their disagreement on Western thought and its relevance to contemporary discussions about understanding and intellectual discourse. Through this exploration, "The Philosophers' Quarrel" offers valuable insights into the interplay between personal relationships and philosophical ideas.