The Moral Gap
Kantian Ethics, Human Limits, and God's Assistance
Format:Paperback
Publisher:Oxford University Press
Published:1st May '97
Currently unavailable, and unfortunately no date known when it will be back
Joint winner of the of the best book exhibiting original Christian scholarship 1997, awarded by the Institute for Advanced Christian Studies
Is morality too hard for human beings? Kant said it was, except with God's assistance. This book looks at the philosophers - from Kierkegaard to Swinburne and the author's father, R M Hare - and the alternative in Christianity.This book is about the gap between the moral demand on us and our natural capacities to meet it. John Hare starts with Kants statement of the moral demand and his acknowledgement of this gap. Hare then analyses Kants use of the resources of the Christian tradition to make sense of this gap, especially the notions of revelation, providence, and Gods grace. Kant reflects the traditional way of making sense of this gap, which is to invoke Gods assistance in bridging it. Hare goes on to examine various contemporary philosophers who do not use these resources. He considers three main strategies: exaggerating our natural capacities, diminishing the moral demand, and finding some naturalistic substitute for Gods assistance. He argues that these strategies do not work, and that we are therefore left with the gap and with the problem that it is unreasonable to demand of ourselves a standard which we cannot reach. In the final section of the book, Hare looks in more detail at the Christian doctrines of atonement, justification, and sanctification. He discusses Kierkegaards account of the relation between the ethical life and the Christian life, and ends by considering human forgiveness, and the ways in which Gods forgiveness is both like and unlike our forgiveness of each other. The book is intended for those interested in both ethical theory and Christian theology.
an impressive book * The Expository Times *
This book is a very careful piece of moral philosophy. Anyone interested in the intersection of religion and moral values should find food for thought. * Mark R Talbot, Wheaton College, Journal of Beliefs and Values *
this careful, rigorous contribution to the series of Oxford Studies in Theological Ethics looks prudently round the corners, investigates the blind alleys, turns over the stones, and leaves the reader intellectually stretched and well instructed, if not greatly inspired. Hare's is a worthy undertaking to remind us of the Christian dimensions to our philosophical traditions, to demonstrate "the credibility of a God who loves us enough both to demand a high standard from us and to help us to meet it". It is heavy, steady, rigorous, demanding reading. * The Ven. David Atkinson, Archdeacon of Lewisham, Church Times *
With the book under review written by the son of a famous father, it is fascinaitng to observe their very different approaches ... the most impressive section of the book lies in his treatment of the impact of Christ on ethics, where a strong defence of the notion of incorporation is offered, and he gives a good critique of Richard Swinburne on forgiveness. * David Brown, University of Durham, Theology *
This is a worthwhile book which interestingly ventilates the problem of the gap between what we ought to do and what we can do. It would be useful as a teaching book ... John Hare is clear-minded and fair-minded, and he writes plainly and lucidly. He aims at being accessible ... and succeeds remarkably well, not only in presenting his own arguments, but in expounding the thought of other people ... The book is practical in giving plenty of applications and examples. * Helen Oppenheimer, Journal of Theological Studies, Vol. 48, No. 1 Apr '97 *
This book is a very careful piece of moral philosophy ... Anyone interested in the intersection of religion and moral values should find food for thought. * Journal of Beliefs and Values *
This is a singular contribution to the reintroduction of Kant's ethics into the contemporary debates in philosophical and theological ethics. * Choice *
A fine argument-packed book ... an informed, skillful and persuasive interpreter of Kant's ethics ... This unusual, resourceful, well-argued and wide-ranging book on a topic of manifest importance should be bought or ordered for the library, and read. * Theology in Scotland *
All told, this book can give anyone who works through it a better grasp of what it means to be moral and of how Christianity addresses the gap that even most secular philosophers find to yawn between what we are and what we ought to be. * First Things *
- Winner of Joint winner of the of the best book exhibiting original Christian scholarship 1997, awarded by the Institute for Advanced Christian Studies.
ISBN: 9780198269571
Dimensions: 215mm x 137mm x 18mm
Weight: 432g
302 pages