Smoke Signals for the Gods

Naiden is the first scholar to pull together so many accounts of sacrifice in such a sophisticated fashion, and he exhibits a masterful range. His collection of anecdotes and testimonia will benefit generations of scholars, who could only look to the abbreviated entries in lexica or handbooks like ThesCRA, which do not aim to be comprehensive. Naiden embraces the full spectrum and is able to collapse it all into an accessible paradigm based on human desire for divine approval and assistance. It's brilliantly simple and the narrative he creates renders a dizzying variety of ancient testimony and criticism into a bite-sized format. He has effectively dismantled the 20th century theories, creating a new point of reference for Classical studies on this topic. * Bryn Mawr Classical Review *
Naiden's Ancient Supplication cogently demonstrated that supplicating the gods was a complex, multi-stage ritual. He now turns to the act of (especially blood) sacrifice, focusing on the centrality of the ritual in ancient Greece, but with due consideration of Hebraic and Roman practices.... He argues, often wittily, that current explanatory models are constructed of theories, prejudices, and ancient literary evidence, inadequately incorporating iconographic and epigraphic evidence. The author considers the full range of evidence to place the gods as central to the sacrificial ritual. More precisely, he analyzes what those sacrificing expected of the gods (and humans did not always receive what they requested).... Those who follow Walter Burkert, Marcel Detienne, and Jean-Pierre Vernant, for example, may wish to reconsider their understanding of sacrifice.... Essential. * P. B. Harvey Jr., CHOICE *
Sacrifice has long been recognised as the central Greek ritual. Fred Naiden's book puts its study on a completely new footing and transcends the older studies by Walter Burkert and Jean-Pierre Vernant. All students will from now on have to start with his book. It is a milestone in the field. * Jan Bremmer, University of Groningen *
A game-changing book that should be read by anyone with an interest in ancient religions. Intensely learned, and bristling with theoretical insight, Naiden sweeps away the standard paradigm of how animal sacrifice works in ancient Greece, and reveals how that paradigm was shaped by agendas and prejudices of modern European thought. The study of animal sacrifice in ancient Greece will never be the same again. * Ian Rutherford, University of Reading *
A landmark study of Greek sacrifice... Naiden's volume is a joy to read * breezy and witty, but obviously the product of deep exposure not only to classical sources but to modern classical scholarship.First Things *
copious amounts of information and a thought-provoking and stimulating discussion * Carrie Ann Murray, Phoenix *
I would say that this is the most important book on ancient Greek sacrifice to have appeared for many a year. In many instances, Naiden seems simply right, both in his broad approach and in his particular conclusions; at any rate, the book will certain play an important part in subsequent discussions of sacrifice in ancient Greece and elsewhere. * The Heythrop Journal *